Fratelli's Pizzeria is a beloved no-frills eatery located on Tylersville Road in West Chester Township, Ohio. Known for its classic New York-style pizza and calzones, Fratelli's offers a casual vibe with sports on TV for guests to enjoy. Whether dining in, using the convenient drive-through, or opting for delivery, customers can savor delicious and satisfying pizzas made with quality ingredients. With a menu that includes a variety of options such as garlic knots, pepperoni pizza, meatballs, and more, Fratelli's Pizzeria has something for everyone to enjoy. Open on select days of the week, this popular pizzeria has garnered rave reviews for its friendly staff, great service, and tasty offerings. Experience the best in New York-style pizza at Fratelli's Pizzeria.
Amenities and More
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Accepts reservations
- Credit cards
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Free parking lot
- Plenty of parking
- Drive-through
- Counter service
- Bar on site
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Reviews
This is the best NY style pizza I've had outside NYC. I had pretty much given up on Cincinnati pizza. So glad we finally tried this place.
I highly recommend the garlic basil pizza with red sauce. It reminds me of my favorite pizza ever - Di Fara in Brooklyn. Thin, cracker crispy crust. Good sauce. Fresh ingredients. Fratelli's knows what they're doing!!!
I wouldn't recommend getting larger than a medium. The large pies tend to not be as crispy in the center. Also, if you get take out, throw the slices in a 500 degree oven for a few minutes when you get home. You won't be disappointed.
Forgot to take a pic before I scarfed this. All that's left after pizza salad and 2 10" pies. Great zah and an awesome staff that, get this, actually like working here. Had their veggie pizza and added sausage because why not? The missus had pepperoni, which was a bit on the spicy side but still good. (Ranch is too spicy for her, so take that how you want). Wonderful casual experience. Don't miss out.
LarderRoom...Voted LarderRoom best New York Style Pizza of 2022...Fratelli's Pizzeria. So of course we rang in the New Year with family and a few pies. Add some hot sauces and we brought in 2023 with heat! Love the Craiger, The Italian and the white pizza. Heck, I love all their Pizzas. Meatballs are awesome too! See you again soon.
First time here! It was suggested to us because we were looking for a pizza place similar to Westshore that closed a few years ago. It was excellent! The pepperoni was VERY spicy which is why we are giving it 4 instead of 5 stars. For me it made it inedible but my fiancé didn’t mind the heat. We will be back!
Been hearing alot of hype about how good Fratelli's pizza is so we decided to check it out today for lunch. Man all the hype was no joke. They just moved into my top 5 pizza places around. Service was great and food came out fast and fresh. Just got a large pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks, and a salad. I'm thoroughly impressed with how good this pizza is and we will definitely be back regularly.
This was very good pizza. We got one large meat pizza and one medium vegetable pizza and they were both as close to New York style as you can get without being in New York. I think the large tasted more like authentic New York style than the medium, but we were happy with both. Definitely coming back. Friendly staff, clean restaurant, & and reasonable prices.
Good NY style pizza. The plain cheese is great. The sauce has a light, fresh tomato taste to it. Also pictured is a large pizza with Capicola ham, sausage and black olives on one half.
Really good NY style pizza. They use stone gas deck ovens at 600F to cook the pizza almost to perfection. I let them know that I like there to be color on the bottom and crispy but they cooked it just short of perfection. I would drive the 35min again to get another cheese pizza. All of the employees were really nice and didn’t mind me asking questions and being a looky-loo while I waited for my pizza. I would definitely recommend.
This is the best NY style pizza I've had outside NYC. I had pretty much given up on Cincinnati pizza. So glad we finally tried this place.
I highly recommend the garlic basil pizza with red sauce. It reminds me of my favorite pizza ever - Di Fara in Brooklyn. Thin, cracker crispy crust. Good sauce. Fresh ingredients. Fratelli's knows what they're doing!!!
I wouldn't recommend getting larger than a medium. The large pies tend to not be as crispy in the center. Also, if you get take out, throw the slices in a 500 degree oven for a few minutes when you get home. You won't be disappointed.
Forgot to take a pic before I scarfed this. All that's left after pizza salad and 2 10" pies. Great zah and an awesome staff that, get this, actually like working here. Had their veggie pizza and added sausage because why not? The missus had pepperoni, which was a bit on the spicy side but still good. (Ranch is too spicy for her, so take that how you want). Wonderful casual experience. Don't miss out.
Location
6890 Tylersville Rd, West Chester Township, OH 45069, United States
Hours
- Monday Close
-
Tuesday
04:00 PM - 08:00 PM
-
Wednesday
04:00 PM - 08:00 PM
-
Thursday
04:00 PM - 08:00 PM
-
Friday
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
-
Saturday
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
-
Sunday
12:00 PM - 08:00 PM
Liked by Others
